Two very different shapes, one shared job
The Dark Blue Sparkle Fish Pet ID Tag and the Black Oval Star Pet Tag both do the same essential job: carry your pet's name and your contact details on a collar. But they approach that job from opposite directions. One is a small, fish-shaped tag aimed at cats and small pets; the other is a star-motif oval available in two sizes and explicitly built for active pets of all sizes. The right pick depends less on which looks better and more on your pet's size, your engraving needs and how much daily wear the tag will see.
Size and shape: the first filter
- Dark Blue Sparkle Fish: One size only: Small, 30x24mm. The listing describes it as designed specifically for cats and small pets, with a slim, lightweight build for everyday comfort.
- Black Oval Star: Two sizes: Small (19x20mm) and Medium (25x27mm). The listing says it is comfortable and secure for pets of all sizes, and calls it ideal for active pets.
What each listing confirms about size
- Dark Blue Sparkle Fish Pet ID Tag: Small: 30x24mm This is the only size offered, so the fish tag is a fixed choice for cats and small pets rather than something you scale up for a larger dog.

Dark Blue Sparkle Fish Pet ID Tag - Black Oval Star Pet Tag: Sizes: Small: 19x20mm / Medium: 25x27mm The star tag gives you a smaller option than the fish and a larger one, so you can match it to a petite cat or a medium-sized dog.

Black Oval Star Pet Tag
Engraving capacity changes the decision
The Black Oval Star listing states custom engraving is included, with up to 4 lines on the reverse. That gives you room for a pet name, a phone number and additional details. The Dark Blue Sparkle Fish listing confirms custom engraving on the reverse with your pet's name and contact details, but it does not state a line count. If fitting several pieces of information onto the tag matters to you, the star tag's four-line capacity is the more clearly documented option. For a cat or small pet where a name and one contact number are enough, the fish tag's engraving description covers the essentials.
Materials and finish
- Dark Blue Sparkle Fish Pet ID Tag: Deep blue enamel with glitter crystal accents on a fun fish-shaped design with a durable metal base The sparkle comes from enamel and crystal accents, so the fish tag is the more decorative choice if you want a distinctive look on a cat's collar.
- Black Oval Star Pet Tag: Glossy black finish with a raised silver star, made from lightweight steel and enamel The star tag's finish is described as durable and lightweight for active pets, which suits a dog that spends time outdoors.
Who each tag fits best
Choose the Dark Blue Sparkle Fish Pet ID Tag if you have a cat or small pet, want a single small tag with a decorative fish shape, and only need name and contact details engraved. Its 30x24mm size sits in the range the listing describes as ideal for cats and small pets.
Choose the Black Oval Star Pet Tag if you need either a very small tag (19x20mm) or a medium one (25x27mm), want up to four lines of engraving, or have an active pet that will wear the tag through rough-and-tumble days. The star motif is bolder and less novelty-shaped than the fish, which may suit a dog's collar better.
What the listings leave open
Neither listing supplies care or cleaning instructions, so we cannot tell you how to clean either tag beyond ordinary gentle handling. The fish tag's listing does not state an engraving line limit, and the star tag's listing does not give a weight in grams. If those details are critical, check the product page or contact the store before ordering. Both tags include a split ring for collar attachment, according to their listings, but neither specifies ring size or metal type.



